Friday, September 18, 2015
The 1898-1902 Numeral Issue
Background and Overview
As stated in my previous post, the Maple Leaf Issue had only been in use for a few months, when French speaking Canadians began to complain about the fact that they could not read the inscriptions. Thus a decision was made to replace the set, with a similar one, showing actual numerals in the corners rather than maple leaves. The replacement was not all done at once, but rather in stages, as new values were either required due to changes in postal rates, or as existing supplies of the Maple Leaf issue were exhausted. The stamps from this set appeared in the following order:
June 17, 1898 - the 1c green and 3c carmine
August 27, 1898 - the 6c brown
September 2, 1898 (earliest known date) - 2c purple
September 6, 1898 - the 1/2c black
September 24, 1898 -the 8c orange
November 5, 1898 - the 10c brown violet
July 3, 1899 - the 5c blue on bluish
August 22,1899 (earliest known date) - 2c carmine
December 24, 1900 - the 20c olive green
December 29, 1902 - the 7c olive yellow
This set was in use for almost five years until the Edward VII issue replaced it on July 1, 1903. Given that Queen Victoria died on January 24, 1901, it took the post office department almost a year and a half to replace the set after her death. As a matter of fact, the 7c olive yellow is actually solidly an Edward VII era stamp, even though it bears the Queen's portrait.
The 2c carmine and 7c olive yellow were issued because of the reduction in postage rates for both local and US letters from 3c down to 2c that took effect on January 1, 1899. The registration fee at this time for all letters was 5c, so the 7c value was needed for registered letters after the rate reduction. But it was issued almost 3 years later than needed.
The 20c olive green replaced the 20c vermilion Widow's Weeds, presumably because the post office department wanted to save money by streamlining printing and reducing the size of the stamps. It appears that some consideration was also given to replacing the 15c Large Queen and 50c blue Widow's weeds, as 15c and 50c values were prepared in essay form, using the exact same designs as the issued stamps. For some unknown reason it was decided not to issue either the 15c or 50c values. In the case of the 15c, the reason was likely due to changes in postage rates, and the perception that it was no longer needed. But in the case of the 50c the reason remains unclear. The decision not to issue values higher than 50c continued and would stand until 1923, when the $1 Admiral was issued.
The points of interest with this issue are much the same as the Maple Leaf Issue, except that the scope is greater: there are more re-entries and plate flaws to be found and more shades, as well as paper varieties. Some of the stamps are surprisingly scarce, such as the 6c, 8c and 20c, while the low values are ultra common in used condition. Thus it is possible for a collector of limited means to have a lot of fun with the low values in either mint or used condition, while waiting for the means to pursue the most expensive material. A wealthy collector can spend a great deal of money on this set, especially if plate blocks are desired, although not nearly as much as the Jubilee Issue.
The Stamps and Quantities Issued
6,800,000 issued 313,900,000 issued
72,021,200 issued 619,000,000 issued
51,287,600 issued 22,070,000 issued
560,000 issued 1,515,000 issued
893,800 issued 2,725,000 issued
As you can see, the quantities of the 1c, both 2c and the 3c were just massive, with the 5c not being far behind. But when you compare the quantities of the 6c, 7c, 8c, and 20c with the rest of the values their scarcity becomes immediately apparent. The 10c was issued in greater quantity, but because most of them were used on parcels or bulk mailing receipts, they are quite hard to find as well, especially with nice CDS cancels.
Points of Interest
The main points of interest for this issue are:
1. Essays, die proofs and plate proofs
2. Imperforate pairs and imperforate between varieties
3. Shade varieties
4. Paper varieties
5. Re-entries and plate flaws
6. Plate multiples and other multiples
7. Postal history
8. Cancellations including precancels
9. Booklet panes and complete booklets
10. Stitch watermarks
11. Postal stationery
12. 2c on 3c surcharges and the Port Hood Provisionals
I will now discuss each in detail.
Essays, Die Proofs and Plate Proofs
This is the first issue that I am aware of in which not all of the denominations originally intended were issued. Collectors may be surprised to learn that there was originally a 4c, a 15c and 20c planned for this issue. These exist in essay form, in a variety of colours. I once saw a 15c in a dull greenish grey. But I must confess that I have never seen the full range of what exists. I have seen die essays printed on card, in olive-black with the American Bank Note Company imprint at the bottom. These essays are all very rare to unique and would set you back several thousands of dollars.
Also very rare are the large die proofs printed on India paper and affixed to card and die sunk. They exist in black and in the issued colours. They are all worth several thousand dollars each.
Finally, and much more affordable are the issued plate proofs. They are printed on India paper as well , in the issued colours and are usually found affixed to card. The number of these proofs that were sold at the 1990 American Banknote Company Archive sale varied between 197 of the 6c and 551 of the 2c carmine. No plate proofs of the 2c purple were sold. These numbers are still relatively low, but despite this, most can be had for around $200 each.
Imperforate Pairs and Imperforate Between Varieties
The 1/2c black can be found imperforate in a gutter strip of 4, as a pair imperforate vertically, and finally as a pair imperforate horizontally. All of these varieties were all produced without gum.
The 1c green, 2c carmine die 1, 5c dark blue, 6c brown, 8c orange, and 10c brown violet can all be found in imperforate pairs that were gummed. In addition, a separate printing of pairs without gum was issued for the 1c green, 2c carmine dies 1 and 2, 5c blue, 7c olive yellow, 8c orange, 10c brown violet and 20c olive green. Where a value exists both with and without gum, they will generally differ either by paper type, shade or both.
The 2c carmine die 1 is known in an imperforate gutter strip of 10, as well as in imperf tete-beche pairs (from booklets) and in complete imperforate tete-beche booklet panes. A tete-beche pair is one in which the second image is upside down relative to the first image.
All of these varieties are rare.
Due to the very large number of stamps printed, there is a large range of collectible shades on this issue. Even in the scarcer stamps, shade variations can be found that are noticeable. The following list is by no means exhaustive, but gives you some idea of what exists for this issue:
1/2c deep jet black (no dullness whatsover to the black)
1/2c deep grey black
1/2c grey black (Untrade calls this shade grey)
1c dull green
1c deep blue green
1c blue green
1c grey green
2c bright purple
2c deep purple
2c dull purple
2c dull violet
2c reddish purple
2c pale reddish purple
2c deep reddish purple
2c pale carmine red
2c carmine red
2c deep carmine red
2c rose carmine
2c bright rose
3c deep rose scarlet
3c deep carmine red
3c carmine red
3c deep bright carmine
3c bright carmine red
5c deep blue
5c dark blue
5c deep bright blue
6c yellow brown
6c bright brown
6c dark yellow brown
7c yellow olive
7c deep yellow olive
7c olive yellow
7c pale olive yellow
7c greenish yellow
7c golden yellow
8c deep bright orange
8c bright orange
8c brown orange
10c dull brown violet
10c pale brown violet
10c brown violet
10c deep brown violet
20c olive green
20c dull olive green
An interesting specialty would involve trying to identify all the shades and then use statistical analysis to determine the relative scarcity of each one.
Like the prior issue, nearly all the stamps were issued on both horizontal and vertical white wove. However, in addition to this, a toned horizontal and vertical wove paper were also used. It would appear that every value can be found on all types of paper, though it is worth mentioning that I have not come across any 20 cent stamps or 3c stamps on horizontal wove paper. The 5c appears to exist primarily on horizontal wove paper and one can find at least two types of the bluish paper. One is a deep blue, while the other is much paler, almost being white. If you were to combine a study of the papers,with a study of the shades, the scope would be very vast indeed.
In addition to varying in both colour and the direction of the weave, the paper varies in thisckness as well. The paper on used stamps usually measures between 0.003-0.0035" and on mint stamps between 0.0035-0.004". Thick toned paper can be found on several values including the 2c purple, and this paper measures between 0.0045-0.005" on the mint stamps.
Unitrade has begun to take note of some of these variations, but I am sure they do not even come close to listing them all.
Re-Entries and Plate Flaws
Unitrade lists re-entries for all values except the 6c, 8c and 20c, though the best stamps to study these are the 1c, both 2c values and the 3c. The areas of the design that are most affected are the shading lines in the corners (spandrels) the lettering, the numerals and numeral boxes and the maple leaves. There are dozens of possibilities for each of these stamps. Unitrade only lists the major re-entries in each case, though Ralph Trimble, the premier student of re-entries identifies most of them on his website.
A number of misplaced entries exist on this issue, some of which are quite spectacular:
1. On the 1c, elements of the 10c design can be seen near the margin just above the right numeral box.
2. On the 1c the upper right corner design can be found 4.3mm too low in the margin and in the lower right numeral box.
3. On the 5c a thin band of the upper frameline of another value appears to pass through the first "N" of "Canada" and the "A" of "Postage"
4. On the 7c, the upper frameline can be found repeated accross the "S" of "seven" and the "S" of cents as shown below:
You have to look very carefully to see these varieties, but if you look carefully you see ink in the white part of the lettering where there shouldn't be any and then you will notice the extra frameline running across the entire stamp.
Plate flaws consist mostly of marks resulting from damage to the plate, like the "C" flaw on the 2c purple, or the hooked 2 on the 2c carmine. However an engraver's slip can be found on the 20c. Actually I have seen two on this stamp. The one that is NOT listed in Unitrade is shown below:
You can just make out this flaw as a diagonal line protruding from the upper right corner of the right numeral box.
Despite the amount of study that has been done on these stamps, I am pretty confident that there are still a lot of varieties waiting to be discovered. None of the varieties I have mentioned here were known 20 years ago.
Plate Multiples and Other Multiples
Used multiples of every value other than the 1/2c and 1c are all scarce to rare, particularly on values above the 3c. You could put together a very desirable group of these multiples by acquiring them from sellers who do not appreciate their significance.
Plate blocks of 8 exist of all values in this issue and for the low values many plates were used to print the stamps. So you could easily spend a lifetime seeking examples of them all, not to mention spending a lot of money. Expect to pay anywhere from 50-100% more than what the individual stamps in the block would cost you.
As with the previous issues, advertising covers continued in their popularity so that very attractive collections of the low-value drop, US and local covers can be formed.
The 1/2c black was issued to pay the printed matter rate, but covers rated correctly with a single stamp are rare. Below is a postcard sent to Algeria in 1909 where this stamp has been used to pay the printed matter rate for postcards that were sent thus in a mass mailing.
The 1c, 2c, 3c and 5c, 7c and 8c are all relatively easy to find on cover. However the 6c, 10c and 20c are all rare. The 6c did not correspond to any rate except for the double weight local letter rate prior to January 1, 1899. Since most local letters would have weighed less than an ounce, this value would not have seen much use. The 10c and 20c stamps were mostly used on parcels and bulk mailing receipts or tags rather than covers, but occasionally one does come across them.
The rate reduction from 3c to 2c that took effect on January 1, 1899 creates a situation where it is possible to find covers that are incorrectly rated and where this was not caught by the authorities.
Destinations other than the US and the UK are all scarce and highly desirable, although my feeling is that Germany is the next most common one. A real rewarding challenge would be to seek out these foreign usages, some of which will be very rare. For example there are probably fewer than 10 examples of mail to Algeria from the time period of the above card.
Again this issue affords the cancel collector with unparalleled opportunity to collect tens of thousands of CDS town cancellations on the low values. A greater challenge is to look for them on values that were not usually cancelled with CDS's like the 5c, 6c, 7c, 8c, 10c, and 20c. Most of the 5c stamps and 6c stamps are cancelled with barred grids. The 7c and 8c stamps are most commonly found with the heavy oval black "R" cancels, as these stamps were primarily intended for use on registered letters. Finally the 10c and 20c are most commonly found either roller or smudge cancelled.
Corks are very occasionally found on the low values, though not that often.
Squared circles are found primarily on the 1c, 2c and 3c values and many hundreds can be collected.
Booklets and Booklet Panes
Canada's first booklets were issued during the life of this series. Very few panes or complete booklets have survived intact. The only value issued was a pane of six 2c carmine die 2 that sold for a 1c premium over face value.
This booklet was only issued in English format and has the distinction of also being the first booklet issued for the entire British Commonwealth. These booklets sell for thousands of dollars, with an intact pane of 6 still being worth over $1,000. Even used singles from these panes are worth more than $10 per stamp compared to just pennies for the regular sheet stamps.
A stitch watermark occurs during the paper making process when the reems of paper are stitched together. It resembles a line of stitching running either horizontally or vertically. Because it only occurs very infrequently in the process and due to the low survival rate of printed stamps, these markings are extremely rare and have only begun to be discovered by philatelists in recent years. It is through the study of large hoards of used stamps that these types of varieties have been discovered. Unitrade lists a few of them for hundreds of dollars each. Undoubtedly they could potentially exist on all values and in mint condition as well. So check all your stamps carefully.
The illustration below shows a horizontal stitch watermark on a 1/2c Small Queen
During this period virtually every form of postal stationery that is in use today was in use:
Stamped envelopes were issued using an embossed relief portrait of the old Queen in a 3c red, and then in 1898, a portrait of the young Queen was used for 1c green, 2c violet and 2c red values. In mint condition these are fairly common, but some used emvelopes are scarce, especially those that have been uprated to foreign destinations. 2c on 3c surcharges are found on the 3c envelopes as for the issued stamps as discussed below.
Postcards, letter cards and post bands continued to use the 1c green design for the Maple Leaf issue, and no replacement cards or post bands were issued for the new design. The 3c letter cards were also surcharged down to 2c in 1899 when the rates dropped. Some of these surcharges are quite scarce, especially in used condition.
The 2c on 3c Surcharges and Port Hood Provisionals
The reduction in postage rates in 1899 created a huge run on 2c stamps that was so unprecedented that the post office ran out of 2c stamps. The rate reduction and the standard UPU colours (the Universal Postal Union had a standard colour scheme for stamps so that foreign postal clerks would know whether sufficient postage was paid) meant that purple was no longer a suitable colour for the 2c stamp. While the 2c carmine was being printed it was decided that the 3c remainders from both the preceding Maple Leaf issue and this issue would be used up by overprinting them "2 Cents: as shown on the block below.
These stamps can be found in a variety of shades, with numerous re-entries and several varieties of overprint have been identified, including a narrow spacing variety between the overprint on adjacent stamps of 4mm versus the normal 7mm. Inverted overprints have been seen as well, though experts question their authenticity.
Finally, perhaps the rarest items of all are the Port Hood Provisionals. They were not officially authorized, but came about when the postmaster of a little town called Port Hood in Nova Scotia decided to take 3c stamps and make his own 2c and 1c stamps. For the 2c he cut 2/3rds of a 3c stamp and used a violet rubber handstamp to stamp a "2" over the "3". For the 1c, he took 1/3 of a stamp and handstamped a "1". They are exceedingly rare. A cover that recently sold at a Spink sale is shown below.
I am currently selling dozens of stamps from this set in my e-bay store, including the basic stamps shown at the beginning of the post. To view my complete selection, click on the following link:
I have been passionate about stamps and postal history since I was 6 years old. I am a Chartered Accountant in good standing with the Ontario Institute. I was until July 2015 a partner of a mid-sized Toronto firm. I left in July 2015 to pursue my passion of full time stamp dealing.